Brushless motor recommendation

I am currently working on a scientific project that requires precise and continuous low-speed rotation using brushless motors. I am contacting you to ask for advices in choosing the appropriate brushless DC (BLDC) motors and electronic speed controllers (ESCs) for this application.

The project involves rotating a lightweight platform (under 500 grams) continuously over a period of 12 days. The rotation must be slow and smooth, with the speed and direction changing randomly approximately every 20 seconds. The desired speed range is between 0 and 2 RPM. The motors will be controlled by a Raspberry Pi Pico that will generate standard PWM signals to set the speed through the ESCs. I am currently using two SM-s4315R servos (standard size), and they work fine for the torque but aren’t meant to function for such a long a continuous period of time.

The ideal motor and ESC combination should meet the following requirements:

  • Ability to operate at very low speeds (as low as 0.5 RPM) with smooth and reliable rotation
  • Quiet operation, suitable for use in a laboratory environment
  • Long-term durability for continuous operation over several days
  • ESCs that accept standard PWM input (1000–2000 µs) and support low-speed control
  • I am currently using a 5V power supply, but I could change if needed

If you have motors (such as gimbal-type brushless motors) and ESCs that you believe would be suitable for this application, I would be very grateful for your recommendations.

Thank you very much for your help!

@bobotibodo This means ensuring the motor does not get hot, and without going to an AC motor, you’ll need to ensure it’s consuming as little current as possible compared to its max. Most BLDC motors are intended to move a lot faster than 1 to 2 rpm, meaning the motor will need to have a very low KV. Another way is to pair it with a very high gear down. The only non-geared BLDC I’m aware of are those used for gimbals, but even so, move faster than 0-2rpm.

2rpm but 12V: https://www.robotshop.com/products/e-s-motor-dc-brushless-worm-gear-motor-2430bl-robots-12v-2rpm
24V 3pm: https://www.robotshop.com/products/e-s-motor-dc-brushless-worm-gear-motor-2430bl-robots-24v-3rpm

If the exact rpm is important, you’ll need an encoder.

6V, 12rpm: https://www.robotshop.com/products/dyna-engine-25d-6v-12rpm-9kgcm-brushed-dc-gear-motor-w-encoder

There may be better options in the category above.

1 Like